The Use of Force Analysis
The Use of Force is about a girl who may have Diphtheria, but refuses to open her mouth to let the doctor look at her throat. After much struggle, emotional and physical, the doctor forces her to open her mouth and it turns out she does indeed have the disease. Level Two
o The parents are pretty static characters, they do not change much through the story o The daughter, Mathilda, is somewhat dynamic as she changes from stubborn and defiant (line 18) to broken, betrayed and angry. (last paragraph) o The doctor is the most dynamic character as, through his tactics changes his attitude. At first the doctor tries kindness and almost sides with the daughter over the parents (line 22). As the story goes on he tries scaring the girl into submission and (line 25), as his anger and frustration build, eventually resorts to force (line 28).
o The main conflict is between Mathilda and the doctor. The doctor needs to check Mathilda’s throat to see if she has Diphtheria, but the girl will not open her mouth. o There is also a conflict between the parents and themselves/the doctor. They want to go along with the doctor because they know he must check, but they do not want force or hurt their daughter in order to get her to submit. The doctor’s dilemma is that if he leaves the girl alone he will not be able to check if she has Diphtheria and may possibly die. If he continues on the road he’s going he will have to resort to measures that are socially unacceptable and even cruel. Irony
Please join StudyMode to read the full document
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
The Use of Force Essay
. The effect that the reader gets out of the story is often dependent on who is telling the story and what desired response they want. No matter who the writer is I think the audience would get a different message out of it because they would each portray their individual emotions in different ways and writing styles. "The Use of Force" by William Carlos Williams was told from the point of view of the doctor. There were four characters involved in the story. I believe any difference in point of view would have invoked an alternate response from the reader. Since the doctor was the one telling the story that made it so that we, the audience, saw everything through his eyes. We got his perspective on the situation. The main issue that he was having was getting the little girls mouth open wide enough for a long enough period of time to get a throat culture. Seeing it through his point of view made us see how and why it was important for him to do this. However, if it had been through another character’s point of view we may have had some trouble understanding his reasoning. He did say that he had "fallen in love with the savage brat" and I think this had a big effect on the audience believing that the parents knew nothing about their daughter. It made it seem like the doctor knew more about the child just because he was, in fact, a doctor. As if him having seen her physical appearance for a few minutes had made him an expert on her.
The Use of Force Essay
. The Use of Force The point of view in the story “The Use of Force” is in first person narrative. This conveys inner the inner thoughts of the narrator as the doctor. The doctor is a reliable narrator and an observer. I feel that his personality is brought out in the doctor. So the doctors thoughts and behaviors are a reflection of the authors. As for the setting it takes place at a family’s home. I think it takes place somewhere in the early 1900’s. I think it would make a difference to the story if it were set somewhere else, only because if the sick girl was brought to like a hospital for example, maybe she would have been diagnosed and helped sooner without all the hassle that occurred at the house. The diction of the story is simple. It doesnt seem too complicated and is easy to make sense of. The author makes his points, and plot of the story clear and easy to understand. The personality of the Doctor is thoughtful. He comes into the house trying to help the sick girl, but after he realizes how shes behaving his personality starts to change. He gets a lot less patient and angrier. The mothers personality is sort of frantic and nervous. Shes worried about her child, and when the doctor has to use other methods of helping her, she starts to become more worrisome and a little annoying. The fathers personality is kind of concealed but nervous too about his daughter. He doesn’t seem to show.
Use of force Essay
. concern with the amount of discretion officers have is their power to decide when to use force or when to use lethal force. Manning (1997) argues that it is generally accepted that police should be allowed to use force. He also explains that there are an uncertain amount people who agree on as to what constitutes excessive force. The line between what is necessary and what is extreme is very thin and hard to see. Use of force is no doubt one of the most important aspects in policing and force should also be used with great discretion. The most important factors to community policing include personalization, partnership and problem solving (Allender, 2004). The idea is to create a relationship with citizens that are both trustworthy and honest. The use of force can include many different actions a police officer can take part in. Force can range from verbal commands, to the use of lethal force. Police need to have discretion to use force to protect themselves as well as the community. When debating the issue of police use of force, the issue of what actions constitute too much force must also be addressed. Another concern is the possibility of corruption amount officers. When given such great.
The Use of Force Essay
. The Use of Force The Wichita Police Department’s policy and procedures on the use of force for its employees takes every measure of precautionary to ensure that the best method of force is used in making a lawful arrest. These policies and procedures go into great detail to inform officers when the use of force is necessary and how much force is needed. An officer of the WPD is justified in using force as long as they believe it to be necessary to effect the arrest and to defend one’s self or another. Deadly force, however, is used when an officer believes such extreme force is necessary to prevent death to one’s self or another person. Before an officer is engaged in the usage of force; he or she must assess whether the objective can be accomplished without the use of a weapon. There are many ways in which an officer can use force to deescalate a situation; some examples are: the use of less-lethal force (this is where lethal force is not authorized and officers should choose what less-lethal technique to use, after assessing the situation.), aerosol weapons, batons, tasers, and, as a last resort, firearms. In any situation that requires an officer to use force; the officer must.
Use of Force Essay
. Law Enforcement Systems | Police Use of Force | | I. History There is an ongoing debate about the use of lethal force versus non-lethal force by law enforcement agents when dealing with dangerous and unpredictable situations. Although many law enforcement agencies have a number of policies that prescribe what kind of force to use police officers often act on their own discretion on whether to employ lethal or non-lethal force. The purpose of this paper is to support the use of non-lethal force versus lethal force in most situations. To some the United States has become a very violent society. Media coverage of the most violent crimes is always covered, especially on the major television news networks. The American people want to be protected and therefore many of them do support the use of lethal force by law enforcement officials, because often what they see with their eyes on the news is usually heinous crimes. However, many crimes which are committed do not physically endanger the law enforcement agent so the use of deadly force is not required. The problem is that too often guns are pulled and individuals are shot without good reason. Some possible solutions are more training in the police academy with less-than-lethal weapons, the invention of.
The Use of Force Essay
. The Use of Force "The Use of Force" is a short story by the American author William Carlos Williams first published 1938. The story is narrated in first person by a doctor, who is answering a house visit to see a sick girl. Fearing that she may have diphtheria, the doctor decides to check her throat. However, she refuses to open her mouth and the doctor uses force to restrain her and examine her throat with a spoon, which makes the girl very mad. The doctor finds that, against her own self-interest, the girl has hidden the symptoms of diphtheria from her parents and the doctor. The story is written without the use of quotation marks, and the dialogue is not distinguished from the narrator’s comments. The story is rendered from the subjective point of view of the doctor, and explores his subdued enjoyment of forcefully subduing the stubborn child in an attempt to acquire the throat sample. The overall theme of the story revolves around power and submission and the doctor’s unnerved feeling following the forceful encounter. The use of force They were new patients to me, all I had was the name, Olson. Please come down as soon as you can, my daughter is very sick. When I arrived I was met by the mother, a big startled looking woman, very clean and apologetic who merely said, Is this the doctor? and let me in. In the back, she added. You must.
Use of force Essay
. 8/1/2014 Use of Force in Syria – Google Groups Google Groups Use of Force in Syria Atty.EDL Jul 30, 2014 11:30 AM Posted in group: International Relations & International Law (P139) International Relations and Public International Law Use of Force Role-Play Simulation Atty. Edmar D. Lerios Good day class! In preparation of your Midterm Examination, which includes the Chapter on the Use of Force, we will have oral arguments (mock trial) about the current events in Syria or the Syrian civil war. So here’s what you’re going to do: 1. Read online (reputable sites, magazines, publication, encyclopedia) about the current crisis in Ukraine. You can visit the following sites for the key facts: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-26248275 or http://edition.cnn.com/2013/08/27/world/meast/syria-civil-war-fast-facts/ 2. Study the DEBATE MAP: USE OF FORCE AGAINST SYRIA published by Oxford Public International Law. Here’s the link: http://opil.ouplaw.com/page/debate_map_syria/debate-map-use-of-force-against-syria#overview There are links to online articles for each sections of the debate map. Read and study only the relevant portions, such as: I. OVERVIEW OF LEGAL ISSUES II. UN Charter Article 2(4) Prohibition of the Use of Force III. Legality of.
Essay about Use of Force
. Use of Force Use of Force Serena R. Smith Grand Canyon University JUS 515 Use of Force Use of Force One night, a small-town patrol officer stops a car driven by two teenagers. The officer believes that one of them might be responsible for a string of recent burglaries. The teens are questioned, and the officer becomes angry at their responses. Over the objections of the teenagers, both teens are pulled out of the car and shoved around a little. They are both told that they are under arrest and the officer begins to place handcuffs on them. Both fight back and both are beaten badly (Bruno, 2010). The question is what legal recourse is available to the families of the teens if any? Let me first start by discussing the use of force by law enforcement. Every day, law enforcement officers face danger while carrying out their responsibilities. When dealing with a dangerous-or-unpredictable-situation, police officers usually have very little time to assess it and determine the proper response (Use of Force, 2010). The United States Commission on Civil Rights has stated “…in diffusing situations, apprehending alleged criminals, and protecting themselves and others, officers are legally entitled to use appropriate means, including force” (Use of.
The Use of Force analysis
• The Use of Force is about a girl who may have Diphtheria, but refuses to open her mouth to let the doctor look at her throat. After much struggle, emotional and physical, the doctor forces her to open her mouth and it turns out she does indeed have the disease.
• Setting – It’s not actually mentioned, but it is implied that it at the Olson’s house, a doctor is called to look at the daughter as she is not feeling well.
o The parents are pretty static characters, they do not change much through the story
o The daughter, Mathilda, is somewhat dynamic as she changes from stubborn and defiant (line 18) to broken, betrayed and angry. (last paragraph)
o The doctor is the most dynamic character as, through his tactics changes his attitude. At first the doctor tries kindness and almost sides with the daughter over the parents (line 22). As the story goes on he tries scaring the girl into submission and (line 25), as his anger and frustration build, eventually resorts to force (line 28).
o The main conflict is between Mathilda and the doctor. The doctor needs to check Mathilda’s throat to see if she has Diphtheria, but the girl will not open her mouth.
o There is also a conflict between the parents and themselves/the doctor. They want to go along with the doctor because they know he must check, but they do not want force or hurt their daughter in order to get her to submit.
• The doctor’s dilemma is that if he leaves the girl alone he will not be able to check if she has Diphtheria and may possibly die. If he continues on the road he’s going he will have to resort to measures that are socially unacceptable and even cruel.
o Although it seems cruel, and almost brutal, using force was the only remaining way for the doctor to check Mathilda’s condition to take appropriate action.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.
How to Cite this Page
“The Use of Force analysis.” 123HelpMe.com. 22 Mar 2018
o There is also the irony that the parents keep telling Mathilda what a nice man the doctor is (line 24), but yet he had to physically force Mathilda to submit.
• In “The Use of Force” by William Carlos Williams, the author uses Irony and Conflict to emphasize the fact that in order to do what is right or necessary we must sometimes do what seems / feels wrong or unnecessary.
Use of Force Essay
There are two types of force in police work. One is non deadly force and the other is deadly force. Non deadly force is force that, when used, is not likely to result in serious bodily injury or death. Now just because it is not deadly does not mean you can run around and be using non deadly force because you feel like it. …show more content…
Deadly force is force that, when used, poses a high risk of death or serious bodily injury to its human target, regardless of whether or not death, serious injury, or any harm actually occurred. Deadly force is the highest degree of force considered reasonable only when used to counter an immediate threat of death or great bodily harm. Deadly force cannot be used against non-deadly force. This means if there is a lesser degree of injury anticipated and or if a lesser degree of force affords an effective defense, it must be used. Once you have gotten out of the way of danger the use of force must stop.
Probably the most famous case that has to do with use of force is Tennessee V. Garner. One evening two Tennessee police officers responded to a burglary in progress. They showed up to the house with the home owner on the front porch saying she heard glass shattering and she was certain that someone was breaking in. One officer stayed in the front while the other officer went to the backyard. On his way to the back of the house he heard a door slam and saw Edward Garner running across the yard. Garner than attempted to jump a 6 foot chain link fence and with the help of a flashlight the officer saw his face and hands and he stated that he saw no
Police Use of Force Essay
the course of duty, a police officer may use force when necessary. The International Association of Chiefs of Police has defined force as “that amount of effort required by police to compel compliance from an unwilling subject” (Police Use of Force in America 2001, 2001). The use of force is accepted as part of police work and is allowed until the force becomes excessive. Excessive force is defined as “the application of an amount and/or frequency of force greater than that required to compel compliance…
A Psychological Approach of Force in “The Use of Force” by William Carlos Williams
“The Use of Force” by William Carlos Williams is a confrontation between a doctor and his young patient. The story is narrated by the doctor. The doctor use of force with his young patient sparks a question whether the doctor is the protagonist or an antagonist or both. We will examine the story as we look at the psychological approach of the doctor and, Mathilda, the sick patient. The biggest conflict of this story is that the doctor needs to check the patient, which is a little girl, but the patient…
Use of Force Essay
Use of Force The use of force is inevitable in police work. In many situations the lives of officers or civilians can be taken by not using force when necessary or using it improperly. Many factors come into play when an officer decides to use force. This includes is the use of force justified, has the officer been properly trained to use force, and will the department be held liable if the force is used improperly? There are two types of force in police work. One is non deadly force and the…
Essay Police Use of Force
Police Use of Force Introduction Police officers are authorized to use force under certain circumstances, for instance; controlling a disruptive, aggressive and disturbing demonstration, undergoing arrest of an accused person or controlling a combative individual. These officers are trained properly regarding use of force while fulfilling their duties. However, the use of force by police is a subject of hot discussion amongst public, as many times law enforcement agencies, televisions, newspapers…
Methods to Reduce the Use of Excessive Force by Police Essay
The use of force, particularly with correlation to officer morale and/or inadequate education/training, has become particularly problematic. Measures should be taken to reduce the injury to suspects, particularly physical injury resulting from poor officer tactics or malicious intentions not related to upholding the law. These are problems, which, if properly handled and rectified, will result in improved officer morale, improved relationships with the public as well as ensure a continued upstanding…
“Use of Deadly Force” Tennessee V. Garner, Et Al Essay
Landmark Case “Use of Deadly Force” Tennessee v. Garner, et al In October of 1974, a Memphis Police officer made a split decision to fire a shot that ultimately ended the life of 15 year old Edward Garner. This choice was made in an attempt to prevent the deceased from evading an arrest based on an eye witness account of a suspected burglary. This action was disputed by the State of Tennessee and the deceased members father, each was basing the argument of very opposite ends of the spectrum…
Essay on Use of Force in Urban Cities and Its Relation to Race
Use of Force by Police in Law Enforcement Name Institution Professor Course Date Abstract This paper seeks to explore the use of force among police officers in law enforcement in urban cities and how it relates with common variables regarding police officers. Some of the police variables that will be discussed include race, education, experience, age. These variables will be comprehensively studied so as to ascertain if there exists any relationship among these variables and use of force…
The Use of Force Essay
The Use of Force, a short story by William Carlos Williams published in 1938 depicts the story of two characters in confrontation. The narrative implies the severity of a situation when social roles and personal impulses intertwine. Remaining polite, patient and understanding isn’t solely for the doctor’s office; it’s a way of life. The Use of Force, a short story by William Carlos Williams published in 1938 depicts the story of two characters in confrontation. The narrative implies the severity…
Force Diatra Farasha In physics, a force is any influence that causes an object to undergo a certain change, either concerning its movement, direction, or geometrical construction. It is measured with the SI unit of newtons and represented by the symbol F. In other words, a force is that which can cause an object with mass to change its velocity (which includes to begin moving from a state of rest), i.e., to accelerate, or which can cause a flexible object to deform. Force can also be described…
A Victim’s Deliberate Use of Deadly Force Is a Just Response to Repeated Domestic Violence
A victim’s deliberate use of deadly force is a just response to repeated domestic violence. According to Senior Senator Dianne Feinstein, “Domestic violence causes far more pain than the visible marks of bruises and scars. It is devastating to be abused by someone that you love and think loves you in return. It is estimated that approximately 3 million incidents of domestic violence are reported each year in the United States.” It is because I agree with Senator Feinstein, that domestic violence…
Essay on The Use of Force, by William Carlos Williams
The greatest question the story presents is if using force for a good cause is justified. William Carlos was a doctor in real life and so the story presents a situation that can be looked by a different perspective by different individuals. The story shows a combat between the doctor and the …show more content…
From the story, William depicts the difficulties that people have towards separating their emotions and standards. The doctor’s behavior towards the girl and the young patient’s reaction emphasizes the subject of this discussion. However, the use of ethos, the narrator portrays his character as a credible doctor in the story. The character of both the patient and the doctor reveal a plausible issue comparable in real life. During this period there is and epidemic of diphtheria, which worsens the situation forcing the doctor to take aggressive measures in treating his patient. Revealed through his words, the doctor first tries kindness; “Awe, come on, I coaxed, just open your mouth wide and let me take a look.” (Williams, 1984) However, the reaction from the girl is repulsive, forcing the doctor to be firm. The young girl’s character shows the conflict of her role as a patient and that of her personality. This is revealed by the fact the she is spoiled and
The Representation of Art in William Carlos Williams' Poem The Rose
The Representation of Art in William Carlos Williams’ Poem The Rose “The rose is obsolete.” (line 1) The rose is no longer of use, out-dated, and out-moded. Modernists felt the same way about the traditional and accepted art of the early nineteen hundreds. Roses are given to people so often. Who among us does not attach some type of personal significance to the image of a rose? I would venture to say that no one has not given, been given, or wished to give or receive…
The Use of Form and Rhythm in William Carlos Williams's poem, The Dance
The Use of Form and Rhythm in William Carlos Williams’s poem,“The Dance” In William Carlos Williams’s poem, “The Dance”, Williams uses the inspiration of a painting by Peter Breughel to shape his poem. Peter Breughel’s painting called “The Kermess” depicts a peasant dance of the mid fifteenth century. It shows the form and rhythm of the dance. Williams also captures the form and the rhythm of this dance in his poem. In William Carlos Williams poem, “The Dance” the open form, suggested images…
Essay William Carlos Williams and His Imagist Poetry
William Carlos Williams and His Imagist Poetry Modernism and Imagism, two movements in literature ,which were developed in the 20th century .At the beginning of the decade ,modernism was a revolution of style .Crime, depression, and materialism filled this era. Musician, artists,and writers broke away from technique to create a new art.Also, imagism brought fragmental and chaotic life where nobody felt secure and happy.After that…
The Great Figure by by William Carlos Williams
“The Great Figure” by William Carlos Williams inspired the famous oil painting by Charles Henry Demuth titled, “I Saw the Figure Five in Gold”. The poem “The Great Figure” contains two of the colors that were then used in the oil painting, red and gold and then using the number five. William’s poem infuses color, light, auditory words for sounds with short descriptive lines that build the scene making it interesting and exciting for the reader. Williams creates the backdrop for the poem by placing…
Essay on A Hidden Hero in William Carlos Williams’ The Use of Force
A Hidden Hero The doctor in William Carlos Williams’ The Use of Force ultimately saves Mathilda’s life but under what motive? His motive to win the battle against her or the motive to actually try to cure her? The fact that Mathilda’s life is on the line brings out the heroic attributes of the doctor in the story. In the end, even though the doctor has malicious thoughts, the doctor is a hero because he ultimately saves Mathilda’s life and continues with helping Mathilda despite her every attempt…
Essay on The Use of Force, by William Carlos Williams
The Use of Force is a short story by William Carlos Williams that is very powerful and leaves the readers with an ethical dilemma. The following social issues can be debated on it: Can physical for good purpose be justified?, What compels the use of force isn’t simply altruism, difference of two separating two different tasks, a dark side persists in every individual, parents concern for their children, use of force as sympathy care for a patient. The greatest question the story presents is if using…
The Works of William Carlos Williams
visible to the eye. William Carlos Williams wrote poetry that, when put under a microscope, the reader could see the true complexity of the poem hidden beneath simplicity. William had an artistic eye, which he must have had inherited from his parents, who were painters (Llanas 47). “William Carlos Williams is as magically observant and mimetic as a good novelist….how well he calls into existence our precarious, confused, partial looking out at the world” (qtd. Jarrell). William Carlos Williams’s poems…
Love Song- by William Carlos Williams
When reading the title, we often associate a love song as something jaunty,pleasureable, and celebrating, or its other extreme, regretting, nostalgic, and full of pity for the singer’s troubles in love. With Williams the singer, the main idea revolves around the concept of an incomplete union in first person point of view, which makes the reading more personal as the reader is using “I” instead you or he. From this concept stem the ideas that this poem is about hopelessness or happiness, communal…
The Use of Force by Carlos Williams Essay examples
The Use of Force In Carlos Williams’s short story, “The Use of Force,” the doctor’s use of force is portrayed in a way that is controversial. Controversial in that it could easily be argued either that the doctor has complete reason to use force upon the girl, or that the doctor has no right to use any amount of force upon the girl without her consent. It could also be argued either that the results of the doctor’s use of force is a success or a failure. I feel that the doctor has reason to…
The Life of William Carlos Williams Essay
of William Carlos Williams “Nothing whips my blood like verse.” These are the famous words of the great poet, William Carlos Williams. Williams was born on September 17, 1883 in Rutherford, New Jersey. He spent most of his life in Rutherford, so today he is a local hero. Williams’ mother was Puerto Rican and almost had pure Spanish blood. His father was American. As a child, Williams’ dad was a salesman and was often away from home. Thus, they didn’t see each other very much. When Williams was…